10 Years of 9/11 Wars is Enough


Media caution and skepticism are in short supply.

Peter HartBy Peter Hart

The 10th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks is sure to bring televised images of somber reflection. Looking back is, in some ways, easier for commentators and pundits than wrestling with the current state of Washington’s so-called “war on terror.”

The United States is mired in two major wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, along with undeclared drone bombing campaigns in Pakistan, Yemen, and Somalia. Launching these wars was fairly easy for the White House, with or without congressional approval. How any of them ends, though, remains unclear. Even the NATO war in Libya, which by many accounts has “ended,” could become more chaotic and bloodier in the very near future.

(Defence Images / Flickr)

The shift from Washington’s time-limited military adventures that followed the Vietnam War — the relatively brief conflicts in Grenada, Panama, Somalia, and Kosovo, for example — to today’s seemingly interminable and endlessly multiplying military commitments is one of the most notable, yet little noted, features of the post-9/11 landscape. Regrettably, too many mainstream journalists seem all too willing to encourage Washington’s new “permanent war” footing.

The Iraq War, we’ve been led to believe, is the one that’s ending, if it’s not already over. Last summer’s withdrawal of combat troops was treated in the press as the conclusion of a very long war. But this summer the news tells a different story: Obama administration officials are lobbying the Iraqi government to hammer out an agreement that would allow U.S. troops to stay beyond the end of the year.

One newspaper called this a “vexing problem” for President Barack Obama, since he’ll have to explain why he’s extending a war he vowed to end. And recent upticks in bombings in Iraq inevitably trigger worry about how dangerous it will be for U.S. troops to leave. This is a strange conclusion, given that this violence is happening while troops are on the ground, and, of course, much of the violence in Iraq is a result of U.S. troops being there in the first place.

Similarly confused rhetoric defends the U.S. war in Afghanistan, where readers are asked to wonder what sort of horrors would take place if U.S. troops were to leave. The White House has a “withdrawal” plan, we’re told; “Obama Moves toward Exit from Afghanistan” was one headline after he gave a speech this summer. A newspaper article called it the “beginning of the end” of the war.

But the facts tell a different story: Even if the White House withdraws troops according to its proposed schedule, by 2012 the number of U.S. troops still fighting that war will be higher than when Obama took office. It’s downright strange to call that the “end” of anything.

Never-ending war has a domestic component too, of course. Massive police and law enforcement resources have been dedicated to racial and ethnic profiling, along with dubious terror “busts” that often turn out to be little more than schemes to goad people into talking about taking actions they probably wouldn’t undertake on their own. As Mother Jones magazine recently revealed, many of the domestic terror prosecutions since 9/11 have been the result of a dramatic increase in the use of informants and undercover operatives posing as would-be terrorists seeking to incite others to action. But each new “terror bust” is treated as big news, one more victory in the “War on Terror.”

After a decade of false alarms and fizzling terror plots, you’d think the media would be more skeptical of government warnings — and perhaps even exercise a little restraint. But then in July came word of a new al-Qaeda threat: terrorists who will sew explosives inside themselves. It was dubbed a “nightmare scenario” on NBC Nightly News. More cautious analysts pointed out that the difficulties in actually pulling off such a stunt would be considerable. But in a seemingly endless war on terror, media caution and skepticism are still in short supply.

Peter Hart is FAIR’s activism director. www.fair.org

Related articles

Advertisements

13 Comments

Filed under Crime, History, Human Rights, Opinion, Politics, WAR

13 responses to “10 Years of 9/11 Wars is Enough

  1. 1. We had no reason to be in Iraq, but thanks to Bush, well you know the rest.
    2. When we into Afghanistan, it was the sole purpose to get bin-Laden, and then get out. Bin-Laden instead is hiding out in Pakistan.
    3. Lybia, when will this crap ever end?, and where will end up fighting next? Iran?

  2. That was an interesting post and I hadn’t seen that graphic before, it’s quite telling. I’m gonna break my tradition of not commenting on political posts here:
    How anyone can still believe anything our government tells us is beyond me. It’s downright shameul how much we’ve been lied to over and over again. Let’s see, the FDA, USDA, DEA among others and mosts assuredly Dept of Homeland Sec! Hey I’m just a girl here but personally I believe we should stay the hell out of everyone’s elses business, get our troops home and line ’em all up on the borders to protect us from the masses of people who are pissed as hell at us. We’re gonna need protectin’! Vote Libertarian, I will!

    • Hi Lynn. Thanks for breaking tradition here. Libertarian, upon closer examination, is an odd combination of social liberalism and fiscal conservatism. Ron Paul is well worth listening to, and/or supporting. You might also check out the post below about AmerciansElect.org

      • Smart of the terrorist wasn’t it….throw a stone ( or in this case several planes) and watch the US came a running after them. End result, they successfully weakened America. I believe it was their strategy all along.

  3. One of the greatest casualties of 9/11 has been our individual rights and freedom – taken from us, not by terrorists, but by our own Governments!

    The other great casualty of 9/11 is ‘TRUTH’

  4. Pingback: Never forget this either | Whatever Works

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s